Call yourself a perfectionist? Then it’s highly possible that you’re over 40. Perfectionism is no longer seen as a badge of honour by employees and organizations. While perfectionism helped columnist Julia Hart build her career, hindsight has changed her feeling about the trait.
Columnist Julia Hart
When I was at the start of my career and asked in a job interview what my weaknesses were, I would always answer ‘I’m a perfectionist’. It felt like a winning reply; my weakness was working hard and trying to deliver something that was 100% right – who could resist? And, more often than not, the person sitting opposite me would smile and continue the interview.
Fast forward 30 years and the world is a very different place; one where, rightly so, perfectionism is no longer seen as a badge of honour but is understood to be an issue that can have a huge impact on mental wellbeing.
So, why was it okay to wear this as a badge of honour back in the late 80s and 90s?
Two reasons, I believe. One is the highly competitive working culture of the time. When I started working in big businesses in the early 1990s, you were expected to start at the bottom of the ladder, work hard, keep your opinions (and voice!) to yourself and, hopefully, at some point you’d get that promotion and climb a rung higher. And then the whole cycle would begin again. Being able to understand these unwritten rules opened many doors for me.
The second reason is that, in this tough working culture, no one questioned the longer-term impact on mental health. Times were different and the subject of employee’s mental health simply wasn’t on anyone’s radar back then.
Much of the research done today shows there’s little upside to perfectionism. It can lead to low self-worth, depressive and anxiety disorders, high stress in the face of failure and even – in extreme cases – suicide.
You don’t need to live with perfectionism if it’s impacting you. Simply accepting that you’re struggling with it is a good first step. Ask yourself the impact it’s having on you – once you know how it’s affecting you, you can begin to take steps to change. Instead of striving to be perfect, try creating more realistic goals (and see if 90% is good enough). Stop comparing yourself to others around you and try lowering your expectations of yourself.
There’s a great quote I heard and often use in my coaching: ‘Perfectionism is the worst form of self-harm.’ It’s true. Explore the damage you may be doing to your self-esteem and confidence by believing you have to be perfect. What are you denying yourself in this pursuit of perfection? You’ll be surprised by the insights you gain.
I’m glad that times have changed. And that the current generation (both of employees and organizations) are much more aware of the impact perfectionism can have on mental health. Perfectionism may have helped me get the jobs all those years ago but, inside, it left me feeling far from picture perfect.
Julia Hart had over 25 years’ experience of working in international environments – from the newsrooms of daily newspapers to senior executive roles within large corporations in tech, food and feed – before setting up her practice as a professional executive coach. She is author of ‘Insider Secrets; a handbook for career success’ and supports businesses with their communications challenges as a consultant. Julia writes on her own behalf about career matters, (female) leadership and work-life balance.
