Skip to main content

News

The Right Fit

Recruitment is part art, part science and a multi-approach practise. Often, it is about finding the right balance between job-based prerequisites and skill-based competencies, resulting in surprising matches. Read on to find out how two core recruitment approaches, when combined, could possibly deliver the ideal candidate in your executive search.

When it comes to recruitment there's often a question that arises; which approach is better – job-based or skill-based? Well, it's not so straightforward. It actually depends on factors such as the role itself, the organisation’s culture and the industry involved. Understanding the nuances of these two recruitment philosophies is crucial when hiring for leadership roles.

Job-based Recruitment: Power of Precision

Job-based recruitment is almost similar to precision engineering with the aim of finding the right tool (person) for the job. It entails identifying candidates whose qualifications, experiences and skills strictly align with the requirements of a role. Research has shown that job-based recruitment is ideal when hiring for positions that have specific qualifications and experiences as prerequisites.

Roles like Chief Financial Officer (CFO) or Chief Information Officer (CIO) fit into this category. These roles demand candidates who can quickly bring industry knowledge and expertise to the table. Opting for job-based recruitment in these cases can yield results by reducing the learning curve and boosting productivity.

However, there are challenges associated with job-based recruitment. One of the drawbacks is that it can unintentionally limit diversity by focusing on candidates who have followed traditional career paths. This may cause recruiters to miss out on exceptional candidates that may possess other transferable skills such as innovative thinking and creative problem-solving.

Skill-based Recruitment: Art of Adaptability

In today’s fast paced and unpredictable world, adaptability is highly valued. Skill-based recruitment revolves around identifying skills that go beyond job roles. It emphasises the ability to adapt, innovate and lead regardless of the job description. Let’s take the example of a Chief Executive Officer (CEO) who holds the leadership position. In this role, skills like thinking, adaptability and cross functional collaboration take precedence. A CEO isn't just a leader, but a leader of leaders requiring skills beyond what's outlined in a job description.

Various studies, including research conducted by McKinsey & Company highlight the potential of skill-based recruitment. It's a strategy for cultivating diversity as it considers candidates from backgrounds and fosters a vibrant talent pool. Recruiters also report that using a skill-based approach results in talent pool filled with candidates that are better suited to fill positions in the long term.

However, it's important to acknowledge that skill-based recruitment also comes with its complexities. Viewed as a strategy that carries some level of risk, it's worth considering that candidates may not have industry experience. Therefore, it becomes crucial to evaluate a candidate’s adaptability and leadership capabilities. Making sure all references are thoroughly checked is also critical when using a skill-based approach.

Finding the Right Balance

Ultimately, when it comes to finding the right approach in recruitment styles, it never is binary. Both job-based and skill-based approaches often falls short if employed exclusively. The ideal executive candidate is typically a blend of job-based qualifications and skill-based competencies. Their achievements aren't solely dependent on industry knowledge and specific experience, but also on their ability to lead, innovate and navigate through times.

When it comes to recruitment deciding between job-based and skill-based approaches, recruiters should be guided by the demands of the role and the organisations strategic objectives. Striking the balance is an art that involves recognising when industry specific expertise is essential versus when adaptability and leadership skills truly make a difference.

Achieving harmony between job requirements and skills isn't about taking sides either, it's about leveraging the strengths of both approaches. While job related qualifications ensure that candidates meet role expectations, skill-based competencies drive innovation, adaptability and long-term success.

In the aspect of executive search, the true essence of leadership emerges from the balance, between these two approaches. By combining accuracy and flexibility, organisations can identify leaders who not only thrive in their assigned positions but also possess the foresight and adaptability to guide the organisations towards a future filled with possibilities and change.

Want to experience the Nomilk2day approach in finding your next executive talent? Contact [email protected]  to get the conversation started.