Skip to main content

News

The rise of the Glass Cliff: lining female leaders up to fail

How many women are being thrown off the Glass Cliff while no-one notices? Columnist Julia Hart highlights what can happen when women are appointed as leaders at a time when a business or institution is in trouble.

columnist julia hart

Lately, I’ve been thinking about the Glass Cliff. It started with the demise of Liz Truss as UK prime minister and I wondered whether the Glass Cliff could have played a role. Friends I discussed this with are split (after all, her politics were polarizing). But, politics aside, it made me think about some of the organizations I’ve known over the years and wonder: is the Glass Cliff more prevalent that we realise? 

The Glass Cliff is a phenomena that only impacts women. When a business or institution is in trouble, women are often appointed as leaders. Not necessarily for their ability to make transformational change but for their perceived soft skills. And because they are different to the male leader who went before and failed. Bringing in a woman is a way to reassure stakeholders that the business is doing things differently. 

What often happens is that the woman is not given the tools, time or backing to make change happen. And if she is unable to deliver, she is pushed off the Glass Cliff. Arguably, because the people who brought her in knew failure was a possibility and waited to see what happened. In Truss’ case, in the days leading up to her appointment as PM, insiders were speculating that she wouldn’t make it until Christmas; not the best way to start a challenging new role!

If a woman is pushed off the Glass Cliff, more often than not she’s replaced by a man – what’s known as the ‘savior effect’. A signal that the business is back in a safe pair of hands.

I wonder how often women further down the ranks are being thrown off the Glass Cliff with no one noticing; the women in management roles brought in to deal with a controversial or challenging project. It’s not just the likes of other Glass Cliff victims Theresa May, former New York Times editor Jill Abramson, and Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer who are held to a different standard than male peers.

There’s plenty of advice out there telling women what to consider when accepting a potentially difficult role, and it is important to be clear about what you’re getting yourself into. But I believe it’s not the women who need to change but the organizations that bring them in. If you’re appointing a woman for a tough role, understand her needs are different. Ask what she needs to be successful. And give it to her. Be aware that men in the organization – even those who report into her – may lean out to wait and see what happens rather than supporting her, which means the very men who appointed her could be undermining her chances of success. Before she’s even started, the woman is playing a losing game.  

It’s important for us all to remember that success in challenging times is never down to one person – it’s down to the organization and the top team to create the right conditions for success. For everyone.

Julia Hart had over 25 years’ experience of working in international environments – from the newsrooms of daily newspapers to senior executive roles within large corporations in tech, food and feed - before setting up her practice as a professional executive coach. She is author of ‘Insider Secrets; a handbook for career success’ and supports businesses with their communications challenges as a consultant. Julia writes on her own behalf about career matters, (female) leadership and work-life balance.